Friday, 7 April 2017

The Whistling Shrew's World Famous Grand National Runner-By-Runner Guide and Aintree Festival Day 3 Preview


The Last Samuri jumps in the lead with eventual winner Rule The World
just in behind. He bids to carry top weight to victory today.
This is a good card with the ‘world’s greatest steeplechase’ as its centrepiece. The National is still a unique test of stamina, jumping and sheer resilience in the biggest field you will see over obstacles. 29 fences so famous they have names,4m3f and 40 horses. With plenty of live contenders you are looking for one who will stay the trip, enjoy running a big field, is a solid jumper who runs prominently and one who either has the class or the handicap mark to beat his opposition - pretty simple then... Here I preview the race through the big trials before my runner-by-runner summary and 5 (or 6 depending on your bookmaker) against the field:

 

Big Race Trial Analysis

 

Although there are very few back-to-back winners, horses who run well in previous nationals and get into the places will often run well again - The Last Samuri (not a typo!) was a gallant second last year and now takes top weight after running well in other handicaps throughout the season. Ucello Conti (6th) and the well fancied Vieux Lion Rouge (7th) represent the other strong finishers from that race, the latter of whom may benefit from being a year older and more so for the dryer conditions. Just A Par (15th) is the only other finisher to return this year.

 


Vieux Lion Rouge jumps just behind Highland Lodge
Vieux Lion Rouge is the winner of another big trial for this, The Beecher chase over the same fences at the shorter distance of 3m2f where he beat old boy Highland Lodge by a short head (with  Last Samuri and Ucello Conti again in 3rd and 4th) with One For Arthur in 5th. Saint Are fell at the first but has run well in the National before coming 2nd on much better ground than when pulling up last year. The Young Master also failed to complete but looks well-handicapped given his obvious talent at staying trips. Irish fancy Rogue Angel quite a way back in 10th, though staying on better towards the end. He represents the winning connections hear as Mouse Morris/Gigginstown bid for consecutive Nationals.

 

He also represents another key form line in winners of other Nationals and we have in the field horses who have won or run well in the Irish, Welsh and Scottish equivalents. In fact, Mouse Morris and Gigginstown are represented by the two previous winners of the Irish National here in the form of Rogue Angel and Thunder and Roses who both maybe interesting. The Welsh National was well won by Gold Cup third Native River but he was being closed on the line all the way by Raz De Maree who as another old boy is a proven stayer, albeit finishing down the field on his previous attempt here. The Scottish National (in which 2013 National winner Auroras Encore came 1st or 2nd, I can't remember which) was last won by Vicente who is one of the may bullets Paul Nicholls fires at this in pursuit of Nicky Henderson in the race for the trainers title. He came alive on good ground in that race and if nothing else will stay, though he'll have to jump well.

 

He was also 5th in a top renewal of the 4m novice chase at Cheltenham last year behind Gold Cup 2nd and 3rd Minella Rocco and Native River (with Vieux Lion Rouge again(!) in 6th. Interestingly, Measureofmydreams was 3rd. He has shown no such form since but as a result could be well handicapped if finding he takes well to this test. Pleasant Company, Definitely Red and  Shantou Flyer all failed to complete on that day albeit they have all come out to win good handicaps this year, though Shantou Flyers win was not over a staying distance. Pleasant Company beat 4 of todays rivals off level weights on his last outing; Thunder and Roses (2nd), Roi Des Francs (4th), Lord Windermere (5th) and Wounded Warrior (PU). Definitely Red beat The Last Samuri impressively, albeit with a lot of weight in hand (they have the same weight differentiation today)

 
Causes of Causes wins the Cross Country


Speaking of Lord Windermere, it is not often you'll see a former Gold Cup winner at 50/1 for the National. Though his form since has been nothing like that and even then it was a weak Gold Cup. But the Cheltenham Festival has proven time and again to be a good prep for this with  previous winners like Rough Quest, Pineau Du Re and Many Clouds running here before. Rough Quest was of course placed in the Gold Cup before winning in 1997 and with compression being a big part of how the race is weighted nowadays then the Gold Cup horses More of That (6th)and Saphir De Rheu (5th) hypothetically come into this as the well treated and most classy animals in the race. Both have had good and bad days at the highest level and it is uncertain whether this is the right sort of test for them despite promising runs. The Kim Muir has also been a trial in the past but the highest placed finisher from that to run here is Dr Harper (7th) who slips in at the bottom of the weights. Arguably one of the best handicapped horses in the field is Cause of Causes, who bolted up in the cross country; a race previously taken in by trainer Gordon Elliott's Silver Birch en route to winning the 2007 National. Wonderful Charm also ran well at the festival coming 2nd in the Foxhunters and will be interesting under Katie Walsh.

 

Looking back to last year's festival though we find one of the most interesting runners in the field in RSA winner Blaklion, who comprehensively outstayed More of That after the lest fence that day. However, he did go onto the Mildmay Novice Chase here where he was stuffed by Native River owing many to believe that the 4miler form (as mentioned above is stronger). I always got the impression Cheltenham was this horses track but he skipped the Gold Cup to come here and if he comes good for the spring ground he is the other horse with potential class in the race and could be massively well in. While we're on the RSA we may as well mention 2013 winner O'Faolain's Boy who hasn't been at his best for a long time but will hopefully enjoy a good spin around here.

 

So.... If I haven't mentioned the winner somewhere in there we may well be stuffed, but to narrow it down here is The Shrewdies and The WORLD FAMOUS runner-by-runner Grand National Guide.

 

Shrew's Shrewdies

 

I would play the National with 5 against the field to match the 5 places most bookmakers pay (some will pay 6) all each way and then maybe some as reverse forecasts…

 

5:15 - The Grand National

 

Shrew's Longlist: The Last Samuri, Saphir De Rheu, Wonderful Charm, Tenor Nivernais, Blaklion, The Young Master, Cause of Causes, Vieux Lion Rouge, Definitely Red, Pleasant Company, Houblon Des Obeaux, One For Arthur, Highland Lodge, Saint Are, Vicente, Raz De Maree, Rogue Angel, Thunder and Roses

 

Shrew’s Shortlist: The Last Samuri, Saphir Du Rheu, Wonderful Charm, Blaklion, The Young Master, Vieux Lion Rouge, Definitely Red, Pleasant Company, One For Arthur, Highland Lodge, Saint Are, Vicente, Rogue Angel, Thunder and Roses

 

Shrew's 1-2-3-4-5 Against the Field (each way):

 
Pleasant Company 14/1
Saint Are 40/1
The Last Samuri 18/1

Vicente 22/1
Thunder and Roses 33/1

Shrew's Bonus (for bookies who pay 6 places):


Definitely Red 10/1

 

Shrew’s BIG ONES (for the over 40s club): Houblon Des Obeaux 50/1

 

THE GRAND NATIONAL 4m2f78yd

Runner-by-Runner Guide

 

Last year's second carries a big weight
The Last Samuri

Seemingly pays a big price for finishing second last year which came in ideal conditions. Will definitely stay but weight carrying efforts are usually reserved for top class horses and I'm not sure if he'll be as effective on this ground. Is slightly advantaged at the weights against Definitely Red who he finished behind last time out. I expect he'll travel well but it's a big ask. ***

 

More of That
More of That hopes to build on Gold Cup 6th


In a race largely devoid of absolute top quality, this horse could plug that gap. The compression in the weights means that in some ways he could be seen as being 'well in'. I'm not expecting him to take to this test and am prepared to be proven wrong if it comes to it. **

 

Shantou Flyer

 

A good horse but I'd be surprised if he figured off this weight and no form at distance trips despite trainers confidence he'll stay *

 

Perfect Candidate

 

The fact he is this high in the weights shows this probably isn't a vintage National for class, however he did put in a career best performance at Exeter in a Veteran's Chase last time out and has bags of winning form over 3m2f and further. However his three runs in fields of 15 or more have seen him finish down the field no higher than 7th. Will jump soundly and give you a good spin from a prominent position but ultimately may be found wanting come the end under this weight. **

 
Saphir Du Rheu heads a big team for Nicholls


Saphir Du Rheu

Seemed to spring back to life a bit in the Gold Cup, finishing a game and fairly close 5th, they all finished fairly close to one another which suggested the pace wasn't red hot but he's in better at the weights than More of That. He has a squeak on his Gold Cup run and is still a very good horse and is well in on the weights. Jumping can be sketchy though and he hasn't been able to get into the places in distance trips ***

 

Roi Des Francs

Runs reasonably and has always been seen as a stayer so I think he'll get the trip. Will also be ridden prominently so will likely stay out of trouble and can give you a good spin but I'd be surprised if others aren't better handicapped. ***

 

Wounded Warrior

Promised a lot earlier in his career but has shown none of that form this year. Before was at the top table in races over 3m1f having been beaten by Don Cossack and Valseur Lido. Ironically his last win was over last year's winner Rule The World back in January 2015. He's not the worst 66/1 shot but it would be a shot in the dark at him rediscovering form and staying the trip. **

 

Wonderful Charm

A good second in the Foxhunters and teams up again with Katie Walsh. That was his best run this season and could represent a return to form. He disappointed last year when pulled up off a lb higher and it is difficult to like horses who didn't complete on the last attempt. You'd give him a better chance on good ground and odds are appealing given good runs at Aintree before that. Considered at the prices ***

 

Tenor Nivernais

Visually impressive 30 length win in Februrary means he is actually quite well in on the weights. He was ahead of Topham favourite Go Conquer on that day and was 8 lengths to the good against Le Mercury last time out. Unproven thus far at anything beyond 3m but has to be considered on handicap mark alone ***

 
Blaklion has had a moderate season since the RSA
but may have been trained with this in mind


Blaklion

I really don't know what to make of this entry. To me Blaklion should've been campaigned for the Gold Cup as his best form to date is all at Cheltenham, Multiple winner over 3m trips and is a grade 1 performer albeit usually coming in behind better horses at the top table. Impossible to rule out as he could bolt up but also could not take to this at all. ***

 

Drop Out Joe

To be 100% honest I don't have a clue who Drop Out Joe is or how he is this high in the weights without me having heard of him. Whoever he is, I wish him well...Apparently he has won three big field handicaps which is an obvious plus and it seems like he'll like the ground. However has not delivered at the top level and as been off since June which are both big question marks. **

 

Le Mercury

Wasn't too far behind Native River at Newbury but was 8 lengths off Tenor Nivernais last time out. Probably on a fair handicap mark and stays 3m1f but others preferred. **

 

 

The Young Master

A lot to like here. From the same stable as The Druids Nephew who was running a big race two years ago. He had a breakthrough season a couple of years ago and has then run well in big handicaps without delivering until coming good at Sandown last April. Ran a nice prep at Cheltenham in the Ultima but could only manage 6th and fell here in December. Shortlisted but others may be preferred. ***

 

Cause of Causes

Obvious claims and the one who will likely attract Irish money on the day. Three time Cheltenham winner, completing the hat-trick this year with a great win in the CrossCountry -a race won as a prep by the same trainer's Silver Birch in 2006, propelling Gordon Elliotts career forward in the process.

He is a small small horse and these fences do still take some jumping. If he jumps well he has a great chance. I'm just not sure he will.  ***

 

Regal Encore

It's always dangerous to say that a JP McManus horse seems higher than they should be in the weights. The main negative for this horse is his running style as he'll likely be held up which is unlikely to suit on the good ground. No form really at staying trips. Others preferred *

 

Vieux Lion Rouge

Obvious claims. Was a worthy winner of the Beecher Chase touching off Highland Lodge by a nose before doubling up last time out. He stays and was a fair 6th in this last year as a 6 year old in conditions that perhaps didn't suit. ****

 

Definitely Red
Definitely Red comes as one of the best handicapped in the race
but needs to prove himself in a big field.


Obvious claims.10lb well in and won the race The Last Samuri won en route to this beating the same horse by 14 lengths. Staying is likely to be the name of the game with this horse and I have no doubts about him in that respect. However, form in larger fields is pretty poor. Shortlisted on potential but worries about that  ***

 

Ucello Conti

At the risk of sounding like my own echo, obvious claims again especially for a place. Didn't quite stay the trip last year and that was probably on ground he would have preferred the ground last year. However, he's now worse off in the weights than when beaten Vieux Lion Rouge in the Beecher. May run on into a place but I'd prefer others. **

 

Double Shuffle

Has shown best form when upped to 3m on last two starts but has never raced over further. Have to assume he won’t stay until he proves us wrong and this is a big ask for a 7 year old **

 
Houblon Des Obeaux has shown a bit of sparkle placing in big races
could go well at a price


Houblon Des Obeaux

Interesting as he has shown good class in the past and has tumbled down the handicap this season despite showing signs of revival at Uttoxeter last time out and better off in the weights against Raz De Maree and One For Arthur after running in behind them both this season. Probably will be held up which is a negative but given his price he’s worth considering for a place **

 

Pleasant Company

Interesting. Good win over 3m1f last time out beating a couple of these off level weights. Also won over that distance last April… Oddly still had a Supreme Novice entry until the last minute. Lightly raced for a 9 year old and scope for further improvement. Untested over further but most definitely considered ***

 

One For Arthur

Only 5th in the Becher but a very good win in January when stepped up to 3m5f. Seems an out and out stayer. Form of that race has worked out well enough with the second winning and the third and fourth running subsequently well. He’s unexposed and open to further improvement. Shortlisted ****

 

Ballyganour

Best days probably behind him. He was travelling well here last year before being pulled up. Has a chance of staying the trip but others have to be preferred. *

 

O'Faolain's Boy

Classy horse a couple of years ago and has had wind operation after. Who knows if that will have desired effect but you’d be chancing quite a lot to fancy him here *

 

Highland Lodge

Older horse with a fantastic record around these fences but incredibly lightly raced in the last few years. Only beaten a nose by Vieux Lion Rouge to deny him back to back Becher Chases. Has to be considered based on record here though no run since then may be a worry. ****

 

Bishops Road

Would probably prefer soft to heavy ground and didn’t get further than the first fence in last year’s Topham. Others preferred despite decent mark. **

 

Lord Windermere

It may have been the weakest Gold Cup in years in 2014 but this is nonetheless a Gold Cup winner being asked to carry a measely 10-10 in the national... His last attempt came off of top weight and he was pulled up on the second circuit having made a mistake at the canal turn. It wouldn't be the biggest shock in a National, but others preferred. **

 

 




Saint Are
Saint Are has great course form and will much appreciate
the dryer ground


The conditions didn't suit the horse last year. He was winning going over the Chair but gradually lost his place on a stamina sapping 2nd circuit. He's down to a more workable mark again today and will carry just 4lbs more than when second in 2015. HIs form this year has not been great but he was a promising second over 3m last time out when conceding a lot of weight and only being beaten a head. Given the right conditions on the day then there are worse 40/1 shots in the field. ****

 

Vicente

A lot to like about Vicente. 5th in the 4m at last year’s Cheltenham Festival and followed up with a big win in the Scottish National, crucially on faster ground. He hasn’t yet ridden to those heights yet this season but given better ground and a marathon trip I’d expect improvement and he could be off a good mark. ***

 

Just a Par

Seems well handicapped. All his best form is at marathon trips but was another who just didn't get on with the ground last year. As such he is probably overpriced. He is a horse who has on and off days which isn't necessarily a bad thing in the national but I’d doubt this is his going to be his day despite now donning the colours made famous by Alvarado and Cappa Bleu who have placed here in recent years.

 

Measureofmydreams

Has run poorly all season but crucially was 3rd behind Minella Rocco and Native River in the novice chase at Cheltenham. That is top form. Overpriced but a lot to prove. ***

 

Raz De Maree

I'd guess this is the oldest horse in the field and experience is often not a bad thing to have in the National (see Vics Canvas last year). He ran eye-catchingly in the Welsh National when closing on Native River at the line. You can probably forgive his last run. However, in his last attempt at this he finished 8th behind Pineau De Re -Not without a chance of hitting the frame but others may just be preferred. ***

 

Stellar Notion

Completely unproven over this sort of trip but ran well behind Tiger Roll when upped to 3m. You’d be disappointed if there weren’t better suited horses than him in the field despite his class. **

 

Rogue Angel
Rogue Angel's finest hour in the Irish National also won
the previous year by...


Interesting representative for last years winning connections and selection of retained jockey Bryan Cooper. Goes from the front so will stay out of trouble but worse off at the weights than Pleasant Company who was ahead of him in the Thyestes and has a pull at the weights today. I can’t underestimate Mouse Morris, but them be the facts ***

 

Cocktails at Dawn

Massively out of sorts in handicap chases and doubtful stayer *

 

Thunder and Roses
... Thunder and Roses
who finished ahead of Rule the World


Seems to run better in smaller fields with one notable exception being his Irish National win. Probably not that much between him and Rogue Angel but faired better against Pleasant Copmany two starts ago before a disappointing run last time out. Also an Irish National winner but generally poor form in big fields except that win. ***

 

Gas Line Boy

Got as far as the first fence in 2015, but has been reasonably consistent since then. I will quite happily look elsewhere though *

 

Goodtoknow

Handicapped to his best, decent second behind One For Arthurand gets 3lb swing in the weights for a 6 length defeat. Has been pulled up in other starts over marathon distances. Shortlisted at his price **

 

La Vaticane

No form at trips over further than 3m and hard to fancy. *

 

Dr Harper

Showed a return to form when just touched off on New Years Day at Cheltenham but that was best run in a long time and it’s doubtful he was ever most effective over staying trips. *

 

Whats in a name?

 

Of course there is always money for horses here for no reason other than their names: Fans of martial arts films will have to choose between last year's second The Last Samuri and The Young Master. Liverpool and Man Utd fans will no doubt pile into Definitely Red, who may also have some support from the Asian market due to the perceived luckiness of the colour red, which could also produce a gamble on Blaklion. Just a Par was only 15th last year but could attract those betting on the masters

 

Shrew's Shrewdies

 

 A very brief look at the rest of the races… no major fancies but if you want to play the placepot:      

 

1:45 No Hasslehoff 6/1 or Doesyourdogbite 40/1 e/w

2:25 Messire Des Obeaux 5/1 or La Bague Au Roi 18/1 e/w

3:00 San Benedeto 6/1 e/w                                                               

3:40 Lamb or Cod 28/1, Takingrisks 25/1 or Sizing Codelco 16/1                             

4:20 Ballyoptic 9/1 or Snow Falcon 10/1 e/w

6:15 Wakea 7/1

 

 
Yanworth is the star name on the supporting card
But will a step up in trip offer redemption for his poor Champion Hurdle run?


 

 





Thursday, 6 April 2017

The Whislting Shrew - Aintree Festival Day 2





Might Bite clears the water jump on route to Cheltenham success
It's official! I have a favourite horse in training and it's Might Bite - he's a maniac, he's a monster and he's an absolute machine. And is going to take some stopping in the Novice Chase. He's about as good as his price suggests and despite some wayward running up the run in at Cheltenham he still came back to beat stablemate Whisper in a thrilling finish to land the RSA. I'm really looking forward to seeing him go from the front and put them all to the sword again today. Infinitely talented and infinitely quirky means 4/6 is simultaneously an outstanding and awful price... what a racehorse.


The feature race though is the Melling Chase which brings together the best (or strictly speaking 2nd best) in the Ryanair and Champion Chases. Sub Lieutenant put in a bold show behind Un De Sceaux but it was Fox Norton who got closer in his race being only beaten by the narrowest of margins by Special Tiara. They take on last years winner God's Own in a tight heat.








The 'mini-national' - the Topham over 2m5f of national fences is about as much of a lottery as the race itself if not more so. The quality novice hurdlers line up in the Grand Sefton and the Top Novice both of which look like good races with a competitive handicap to top the card, all before something coming through and whet the appetite for 2017/18 in the Aintree bumper.


I will review the whole festival after the three days but one of the big stories of Day1 was the retirement of Silviniaco Conti - 7 time grade 1 winner - and I hope he has many happy days in his new career, whatever that may be.


Shrew's Shrewdies


            Most Likely Winner                              Shrew's Shrewdie


1:45  3 against the field:  Sky Kahn 14/1, Rather Be 10/1 and/or Geordie Des Champs 1 14/1 e/w                                       


2:20 River Wylde 2/1                                        Mount Mews 7/2


2:50  Might Bite  4/6                                          Callett Mad 28/1 e/w


3:25 God's Own 11/4   (Sub Liutenant a big danger)                                                    


4:05 4 against the field: O O Seven 18/1, Clarcam 25/1, Seefood 10/1, Henryville 12/1 e/w


4:40 The World's End 5/2 (nap)                         Ballymalin 20/1 e/w


5:15 Black Op 7/2                                                  If The Cap Fits 5/1 or And The New 33/1 e/w


Race-by-race Guide




1:45 Handicap Hurdle 2m4f


Not the easiest of starts and it's a general 9/1 the field...I'm not madly keen to spend much time on it. One that is potentially well handicapped is Sky Kahn.


I put Rather Be up at Cheltenham before he unseated rather early so I'd give him a chance again having not had much of a race at all. The top of the weights has a few classy horses who I could see running well... Georgie Des Champs stands out as a previous Aintree winner so he might as well be in there too.

2:20 Novice Hurdle 2m
Cloudy Dream was an impressive 49 length winner at Kelso and comes here fresh


A competitive novice hurdle with some of the form from the Supreme Novice going up against horses that have been held back for this meeting. Mount Mews makes a lot of appeal and is only rated a couple of pounds below Moon Racer and River Wylde. In truth it's difficult to know what his actual rating should be given his last win was a 45 length demolition of a much weaker field than this. Malcolm Jefferson was on the scoreboard yesterday with Double W's and Cloudy Dream ran well also behind Flying Angel and will fancy his chances to follow up.


Moon Racer never got in the mix in the champion hurdle and the way he ran to me suggested he probably wouldn't have fared much better in the Supreme - he could easily bounce back and had no sort of race to have taken much off of him. He should be prepped for this. I would have the bigger danger as River Wylde who was a very good third in the Supreme Novice. He will likely be ridden prominently which will suit the course but may not have the same freshness as Mount Mews.


Of the ones at bigger prices you may as well bet American Gigolo over Chti Balko as was ahead of him at Doncaster earlier in the year. The Unit has place claims but why not chance it on 50/1 French import Bulkov.


2:50 Novice Chase, 3m2f                                        
Might Bite vs Whisper round 2


Might Bite is undoubtedly as talented as he is mental and if he puts up a similar performance to the one he did at Cheltenham it will take a lot to beat him. Although he only touched Whisper off by a nose in the end he is miles better than the pure form and I presume on a flat track the jockey will have none of the problems he experienced after the last at Cheltenham. Whisper though is a bit of a course specialist here, over hurdles at least and will certainly be waiting to pounce should the favourite falter.


If they both run up to form then there isn't much each way value in the race but if you want to take one I'd side with Calett Mad who will be better now dropped back in trip.


3:25 Melling Chase 2m3f        


This is a really good race with no absolute standout star. The previous ten winners have all run in either the Ryanair or Queen Mother with the races producing 5 winners apiece. Fittingly we have the 2nd placed horses in both those races in the form of Fox Norton and Sub Lieutenant. Both horses stayed on in their respective races well to close gaps on the eventual winners. Of the two Sub Lieutenant is the more experienced over this trip with good form to his name behind Sizing John and Outlander to name a couple. However, he has failed to get his head in front against both, who are arguably more staying types. Fox Norton has never run beyond 2m1f but stayed on well at the end of the Champion Chase. His run at Aintree last year in the novice chase saw him 32 lengths off of Douvan in third.
Gods Own bids for back to back successes on spring ground he adores


God's Own won this race last year and was still in with a chance in the Champion Chase when almost landing on top of the second fence. He comes good for spring ground and will be better suited by this trip. He was ahead of Fox Norton when making that mistake and whether it was the error or whether it was the hill at Cheltenham finding it out, either way, this course and distance I'd side with him to finish ahead of Fox Norton. It's the wrong way to look at it, but in direct form terms through Un De Sceaux's Ryanair and Tingle Creek respectively Sub Lietuenant and God's Own have 1/2 length between them. I'd expect God's Own to be on the up on the spring ground however so he is just about the selection.


Of the others Uxizandre is a previous Aintree winner and could be the forgotten horse at 8/1 but Josses Hill makes more appeal at the prices given his victory over Tea For Two and More of That at Huntingdon earlier in the season, and a decent run in the King George which is further than his ideal distance.                     


4:05 Topham Handicap Chase, 2m5f


Probably more of a lottery than the National... you could quite easily back four who look good here and have none of them hit the frame. So let's do that...
Eastlake bids for back-to-back success over the National fences


Clarcam and O O Seven strike me as the two class horses alongside Irish Cavalier, but seem more on the upgrade than the latter. I like them towards the top of the weights.


Further down, Dr Richard Newland has had Richard Johnson booked early to ride Seefood and I imagine he'll be in the mix as well as Henryville who has previous good form over the fences.



4:40 Sefton Novices Hurdle 3m


West Approach is officially the best horse in this race but a) his mark is arguably inflated due to running against the older experienced horse and b) it's hard to back anything coming out of Colin Tizzard's yard of late. At worst you'd expect him to finish better than Tizzard's other runner Elegant Escape who faded completely in the Albert Bartlett.


The better part of that form however is represented by Constantine Bay who was a good staying on 4th on that day. But arguably he (and the horses that beat him) weren't travelling as well as The Worlds End before he departed the race two out when starting to get into a good stride. His form going into that race has been very good at staying trips and I would be willing to give him another go.  
The Worlds End bids to get back to winning ways after Cheltenham



If Get On The Yeger were running in the national you'd expect the price to drop drastically from the swarms of 18-30 money coming for his name alone. He's been consistent but ultimately fell short at Group level. Monbeg Charmer is unexposed but this will be altogether a harder test. Testify will also find this a big step up in class for the McCain team.


Beyond Conceit and Keeper Hill were both down the field at Cheltenham but may enjoy the longer trip but I'd side marginally with proven performance over the distance and Ballymalin is a three time winner over 3m and maybe value despite bad stable form.



5:15 Aintree Bumper 2m1f


I'm not madly keen on anything, but in simple terms, Western Ryder was behind Claimtakinforgan at Cheltenham and Claimtakinforgan was easily beaten by Black Op last time out... so you'd assume that the pecking order of those three.


If The Cap Fits has won two good bumpers and for some reason I like horses sired by Milan here - I'm not sure if the stats back that up. Anyway he's 2lbs better than Black Op based on runs so far but any level of improvement could come from either of them. They will both likely be prominent which is a plus.


And The New was an eyecatching 7th in the Cheltenham race. He was held up but perhaps given a more positive ride could take advantage of a fast early pace and pick some off in the straight to earn a place.





Wednesday, 5 April 2017

The Whistling Shrew - Aintree Festival Day 1

Arguably the next two days of racing at Aintree eclipse some of the days of the Cheltenham Festival. Although there was always something of an 'after the Lord Mayor's show' feeling about Aintree for quite some time, the three day event has grown into an extravaganza with back to back grade 1s everywhere you look, all leading up to the Grand National of course.




Cue Card is the star name as he bids once again for
Gold Cup Redemption
The form of this meeting is often trickier to follow with some coming on from the festival and others having been given the rest - the bias of the recent Cheltenham form often skewing the markets, particularly in novice races. It's always good to look out for a horse who has been saved for this, particularly with one with form on flat tracks. It is certainly a good time of year to back a lively outsider.




Day 1 is simply top class despite small fields and sees the Bowl and Aintree Hurdle take centre stage where we will see the best staying chasers take on defending champion Cue Card followed by the Champion Hurdle winner Buveaur D'Air looking to repeat the double achieved by Annie Power last year. A novice and juvenile grade 1, mares bumper, an ultra competitive 2m handicap chase and the Foxhunters Chase over the National fences make this one of the best race days in the calendar (that is until tomorrow)


I have changed the tips slightly to offer a 'most likely winner' based on form and suitability to the race (so will often be a first 2nd or third favourite) and a separate Shrew's Shrewdie if I think that horse is opposable. For some races there may not be a likely winner and for some races there may not be a standout Shrewd selection... The most likely winner represents just what it says it does. The Shrewdie represents the horse with the best price compared to its chance of winning




Shrew's Shrewdies


            Most Likely Winner                              Shrew's Shrewdie


1:45 Top Notch 6/5                                          Frodon 5/1
2:20  Defi Du Seuil 1/3                                    Forth Bridge 14/1 e/w or place only
2:50 Cue Card 13/8                                     
3:25 Buveaur D'Air 4/11                                My Tent Or Yours for 2nd 10/1 e/w
4:05 On The Fringe 6/4                                  Bear's Affair 25/1 e/w or Rebel Rebellion 14/1 e/w
4:40                                                                  Foxtail Hill 11/1 e/w or Raven's Tower 20/1 e/w
5:15                                                                   Oscar Rose 18/1 e/w




It's an interesting opening to the festival and it might be worth betting small multiples with some of the shorter priced horses - namely Top Notch, Defi Du Seuil, On The Fringe, Buveur D'Air and Cue Card. A couple may get beaten (Cue Card and On The Fringe the most risky) but you'd expect three or four to come in.

Race-by-race Guide


1:45 Mildmay Manifesto Novice Chase, 2m4f
Top Notch bids for a second Graded success over fences


A great way to start the festival. This looks a challenging race with two big Cheltenham performers heading the market in Top Notch and Cloudy Dream who were second to Yorkhill and Altior respectively. Top Notch is the obvious choice to be winning this and has only found Yorkhill too good in his last five runnings, three of which have come at this trip. He has a great chance but has been on the go since September and this race is a graveyard for favourites for that exact reason.


Cloudy Dream comes in as second favourite after a good run behind Altior in the Arkle. Altior quickened away from him impressively at Cheltenham, which is partially owing to Altior's brilliance but also makes me think that on this fast galloping track he might not quite have the pace of Top Notch especially being stepped up in distance for the first time.


Frodon on the other hand has amassed vast experience at this distance. Like Top Notch he may have had one too many runs under his belt this year but skipped Cheltenham and comes here off a 40 day break as a horse who is still improving at just 5 years of age, though has been off the same mark for his past three starts.


Flying Angel is also improving. I put him up each way in the JLT but he was hampered fairly early on and never recovered into a position to mount any sort of challenge. At the odds he still represents re good value for a hors who is a winner at this distance.


Cyrus Moriviere and Max Ward both have a lot of improving to do based on ratings and would need a lot of luck in running to figure.


2:20 Doom Bar Anniversary Juvenile Hurdle , 2m
Defi Du Seuil is odds on to follow up on his Cheltenham Triumph


This race has a surprisingly poor record for horses looking to double up with the Triumph Hurdle at Cheltenham - perhaps because of the speed at which it comes up or perhaps because it's the time of year that spring juveniles first start to show the form that they couldn't on the winter ground. In Defi Du Seuil though you'd expect a big performance. He travelled like a dream at Cheltenham and the way he extended after the last makes him a live contender for the 2018 Champion Hurdle or Arkle, whichever race he goes for. If he runs to form it's difficult to see him getting beaten here.


It would certainly be hard to see any of the horses who were behind him at Cheltenham improving past him for the change of track.


Divin Bere is the most likely to follow him home based on his close run in the Fred Winter and is now much better off in the weights than Flying Tiger who beat him by a nose. If there's any value it may be in the Queen's horse Forth Bridge who skipped the festival and could improve sufficiently to fill one of the places.


2:50 Betway Bowl, 3m1f


Cue Card, Cue Card, Cue Card... There is no getting away from the fact that he wasn't travelling in the Cheltenham Gold Cup as well as he was last year. There is also no getting away from the fact that he is getting older and that his form this season has been patchy at best. In fact, barring a good run at Haydock beating a returning Coneygree and an emphatic victory at Ascot he has looked very much on the decline this season. But despite that he is still the best horse in the race and back on a flat track, who knows? Having departed when the race was heating up at Cheltenham one could argue that he has reserved a little energy and there is no horse in training with quite the constitution that Cue Card has. Assuming he shows up in form the question is whether there is a grade 1 opponent good enough to beat him.


Empire of Dirt seeks redemption after a poor run and
 will prefer the 3m trip today
The likelier candidates for that are Empire of Dirt or  Bristol De Mai . Empire of Dirt was given a strange ride in the Ryanair and hit a fence early... He did however travel strongly and the step back up to 3m+ may see him return to the form he was in when behind Sizing John in the Irish Gold Cup. He might win and is the most obvious choice if Cue Card fails to deliver but there is better value elsewhere. A return to a flat track will sit Bristol De Mai who seemed to improve for a step up in distance, there was nothing wrong with his run in the Gold Cup other than he wasn't really quick enough - that's unlikely to change on a speed track like Aintree.

Tea for Two exited the Cheltenham Gold Cup at the second fence but did proceed to run around the outside of the field and jump one of the railings before running down the straight. Nonetheless he should still be quite fresh and a flat track is a plus, his form going this direction as opposed to clockwise though is definitely not. Smad Place will run his race but again is doubtful to be good enough these days.


Aso ran really well in the Ryanair but I think that is probably the peak of his form and he failed to sparkle on his sole attempt over 3m.
Silviniaco Conti returns to one of his favourite tracks
The horse with top quality course form though is Silviniaco Conti who seems to have been forgotten - this may be for good reason as he is now 11 years of age. But he is a dual past winner of this race and will come here fresher than most having skipped Cheltenham. He was close to Cue Card in the King George but arguably Cue Card had expended his energy trying to go with Thistlecrack which made the finishing distances much shorter than they may have been given a true running.


In conclusion, Cue Card can win if he runs to the best of this seasons form. If not Empire of Dirt does assuming the last run was an anomaly and a step back up in trip will bring out his best.


If both fail to do those things it's pretty open but the market has it right with Bristol De Mai most likely of the rest.




3:25 Betway Aintree Hurdle 2m4f
The Champion Hurdler looks unbeatable in this company


Buveaur D'Air expelled any doubts about his return to hurdles at Cheltenham, he was slick and destructive. A return to Aintree where he won as a novice and a step up to 2m4f are further plusses and he should beat this fairly ordinary field with ease.




It is great to see The New One and My Tent Or Yours both lining up against eachother again and they are the most likely for the frame. The New One will prefer the step up in trip but Tent is better off at the prices.  Identify Thief is an interesting entry having completely lost his way as a novice chaser this year but isn't really any sort of proposition.




I assume there is prize money for the first 6 so it will be a nice day out for the owners of Old Guard and they may even beat Rashaan to 5th! 




4:05 Foxhunters Chase, 2m5f
Pacha Du Polder bids for a big double over On The Fringe


Once bitten, twice shy... but that is not the case with On The Fringe who was just never getting there in time at Cheltenham. Arguably that has always been the weaker leg of the treble with this second leg and Punchestown usually bringing out further improvement and I'd marginally have him to reverse form with Pacha Du Polder who flopped here last year after a promising run at Cheltenham.


From an each way angle there's a lot to like about Rebel Rebellion who as won over this course and distance before and comes here as a fresh horse.


I love Big Fella Thanks who has been round almost as long as I've been a racing fan and will definitely have a sentimental bet on the 15 year old.


Sam Whaley Cohen is obviously very good over these fences so has a chance on Black Thunder.


Balnaslow was among the hoses finishing in a heap at the end of the Cheltenham equivalent and may be better suited if going from the front again.


Mr Mercurial looked really good when beating Mendip Express on return from an absence and is also considered.




4:40 Red Rum Handicap Chase, 2m


Malcolm Jefferson runs Double W's who makes  lot of appeal as a progressive 7 year old. He looks marginally better handicapped than Dandridge and Theinval who come here off the back of good runs in the Grand Annual.


Parsnip Pete has good form around Aintree in the past. A the bottom of the handicap Ravens Tower looks like the one with the most improvement but will perhaps not have the race to suit as well as Foxtail Hill  whocould also run well with frontrunning tactics being deployed.


5:15 Aintree Mares Bumper, 2m


Not a clue.... Petticoat Tails is top rated with Irish Roe and Shearling not far behind and that seems to be the way that bookmakers have priced this. Sweetlittlemystery doesn't seem to be there on the ratings but has attracted some support.


Polly's Pursuit is presumably a relative of Polly Peachum who was a very good mare and a nose away from winning at Cheltenham. But Oscar Rose will be a highly tentative selection at a price with potential excuses when below par last time out.